Past Commodores
* Rest in Peace
| *Geoffrey Moore 1928-29 | *Sidney Ailing 1930 | *Harry Denison 1931 | *Robert Burnett 1932 |
| *Cleveland Clark 1933 | *Dr. John Heifrich 1934 | *William Tonges 1935 | *Elwot Avery 1936 |
| *Rev. Edgar Tobin 1937 | *Ernest Saunders 1938 | *Harol Higginbotham 1939 | *Rev. James Graham 1940 |
| *Frank Furness 1941 | *David Howard 1942 | *David Robertson 1943 | *Harold Chappell 1944 |
| *Norman Briggs 1945 | *Charles Davey 1946 | *Joseph W. Kenyon, Sr. 1947 | *Ellsworth Wilson 1948 |
| *David Marshall 1949 | *Alfred H. Chapman 1950 | *Michael A. Tuscano 1951 | *Arthur Smith 1952 |
| *Albert Caldarone 1953 | Andrew Phillips 1954 | *Francis Jennings 1955 | *Edwin S. Brown, Sr. 1956 |
| Edward C. Mueller 1957 | Joseph W. Kenyon, Jr. 1958 | *Edward J. McKee 1959 | *Arthur B. Gervasini 1960 |
| M. H. Koske 1961 | L. W. Taylor 1962 | *Pat DiMaggio 1963 | *Nicholas Furcolo 1964 |
| Paul Pampel, Jr. 1965 | *John Hodis 1966 | *O. H. Bourdon 1967 | *Ralph P. Stott 1968 |
| *Frank DelMonte 1969 | *Robert Browning 1970 | *Daniel Tattersall 1971 | G. Byron Champlin 1972 |
| *Richard A. Matzdorff 1973 | Frank Ward 1974 | Richard Lewis 1975 | *James A. Iacoi 1976 |
| *Kenneth C. Taylor 1977 | *Emanual J. Lauria 1978 | *Robert F. Johnston 1979 | Victor J. Manzella 1980 |
| *Fred C. Friedel 1981 | *Charles R. Wilber 1982 | *Herbert Dobson, Jr. 1983 | Roy W. Richards 1984 |
| *Mike G. Kluck 1985 | Michael H. Lynch, Jr. 1986 | *Daniel M. White 1987 | Stephen DePerry, Jr. 1988 |
| Sal J. Parise 1989 | Jack Robertson 1990 | Gene Frantz 1991 | Donald I. Greene 1992 |
| Ronald E. Lawrence 1993 | Albert Antoch 1994 | Michael Cardinal 1995 | *Emile Hebert 1996 |
| *James Murray 1996 | Ted Steinetz 1997 | Robert Pellegrino 1998 | Gary Latz 1999 |
| Robert F. Raby 2000 |
Robert D. Wydler |
Joseph P. Reis 2002 | Galen Hoffman, Jr. 2003 |
| Edmund L. Curran 2004 | Joseph P. Reis 2005 | Lawrence Harland 2006 | Douglas Noble 2007 |
| Alexander Houston 2008 |
